Reviews
A Wall Street Journal Bestseller
A USA Today Bestseller
“Excellent…Few have grappled as energetically with the complexity of real life as Esther Duflo and Abhijit Banerjee, or got their boots as dirty in the process…A treasure trove of insight…[Readers] will be captivated by the authors’ curiosity, ferocious intellects and attractive modesty.”―The Economist
“Carefully argued and backed with research…Good Economics is an effective response to Banerjee and Duflo’s more thoughtful critics, some of whom argued that devotion to randomised trials had led to a narrowing of economics, in which complex questions that could not be scientifically tested should simply be set aside. The authors make a convincing case that empirical economics contains answers to many vexing problems, from populism to identity politics, especially when economists are willing to range outside their discipline’s confines.”―Financial Times
“Good Economics for Hard Times lives up to its authors’ reputations, giving a masterly tour of the current evidence on critical policy questions facing less-than-perfect markets in both developed and developing countries, from migration to trade to postindustrial blight.”―Wall Street Journal
“Their goal is to ground both sides of our national debate in hard evidence, and the process of coming up with ways to do that is pretty interesting in itself… Eager to distance themselves from the previous generation of economists who argued from first principles, Banerjee and Duflo say nothing that smells like special pleading. It would be hard to take umbrage with such studied humility. The authors admit, ‘We clearly don’t have all the solutions, and suspect no one else does either.’ Even so, the prospect of a path towards consensus solutions through iterated experiments is enough to make for a compelling read.”―National Review
“The studies they cite probe hot topics such as climate change, immigration and the viability of continued economic growth. Banerjee and Duflo synthesize the literature on what is agreed and what is controversial in an accessible, often entertaining way.”―Nature
“Good Economics for Hard Times makes important policy connections and suggestions… Banerjee and Duflo explore traditional remedies (tariffs sure aren’t the answer, they find, and job retraining and other trade adjustment tools are too narrow and take too long) and suggest some novel ideas… In crafting their carefully reasoned arguments, they marshal evidence assembled over decades from all sorts of areas-the fight against malaria, past efforts at tax reform, previous waves of migration-and propose commonsense solutions.”―Foreign Policy
“Lucid and frequently surprising… Banerjee and Duflo’s arguments are original and open-minded and their evidence is clearly presented. Policy makers and lay readers looking for fresh insights into contemporary economic matters will savor this illuminating book.”―Publishers Weekly, Starred Review
“A canard-slaying, unconventional take on economics…This might look like yet another conventional state-of-the-world economics book, but it is anything but. It is an invigorating ride through 21st-century economics and a treasure trove of facts and findings.”―The Times (UK)
“Good Economics for Hard Times lives up to its authors’ reputations, giving a masterly tour of the current evidence on critical policy questions facing less-than-perfect markets in both developed and developing countries, from migration to trade to postindustrial blight.”―William Easterly, The Wall Street Journal
“An excellent antidote to the most dangerous forms of economics bashing…Abhijit Banerjee and Esther Duflo, write beautifully and are in full command of their subject. Perhaps the greatest contribution of Good Economics… is precisely this: it demonstrates both the brilliant insights that mainstream economics can make available to us and its limits, which a progressive internationalism has a duty to transcend.”―Yanis Varoufakis, The Guardian
“Not all economists wear ties and think like bankers. In their wonderfully refreshing book, Banerjee and Duflo explore impressive areas of new research questioning conventional views about issues ranging fromtrade to top income taxation and mobility, and offer their own powerful vision of how we can grapple with them. A must-read.”―Thomas Piketty, professor, Paris School of Economics, andauthor of Capital in the Twenty-first Century
“A magnificent achievement, and the perfect book for our time. Banerjee and Duflo brilliantly illuminate the largest issues of the day, including immigration, trade, climate change, and inequality. If you read one policy book this year — heck, this decade—read this one.”―Cass R. Sunstein, Robert Walmsley University Professor,Harvard University, and author, How Change Happens
“Banerjee and Duflo have shown brilliantly how the best recent research in economics can be used to tackle the most pressing social issues: unequal economic growth, climate change, lack of trust in public action. Their book is an essential wake-up call for intelligent and immediate action!”―Emmanuel Saez, professor of economics at UC Berkeley
“One of the things that makes economics interesting and difficult is the need to balance the neat generalities of theory against the enormous variety of deviations from standard assumptions: lags, rigidities, simple inattention, society’s irrepressible tendency to alter what are sometimes thought of as bedrock characteristics of economic behavior. Banerjee and Duflo are masters of this terrain. They have digested hundreds of lab experiments, field experiments, statistical studies, and common observation to find regularities and irregularities that shape important patterns of economic behavior and need to be taken into account when we think about central issues of policy analysis. They do this with simple logic and plain English. Their book is as stimulating as it gets.”―Robert Solow, Nobel Prize winner and emeritus professor of economics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
“In these tumultuous times when many bad policies and ideas are bandied around in the name of economics, common sense-and good economics-is even more sorely needed than usual. This wide-ranging and engaging book by two leading economists puts the record straight and shows that we have much to learn from sensible economic ideas, and not just about immigration, trade, automation, and growth, but also about the environment and political discourse. A must-read.”―Daron Acemoglu, Elizabeth and James Killian Professor of Economics, MIT, and coauthor of Why Nations Fail
“Banerjee and Duflo move beyond the simplistic forecasts that abound in the Twittersphere and in the process reframe the role of economics. Their dogged optimism about the potential of economics research to deliver makes for an informative and uplifting read.”―Pinelopi Goldberg, Elihu Professor of Economics, Yale University, and chief economist of the World Bank Group
“In Good Economics for Hard Times, Banerjee and Duflo, two of the world’s great economists, parse through what economists have to say about today’s most difficult challenges-immigration, job losses from automation and trade, inequality, tribalism and prejudice, and climate change. The writing is witty and irreverent, always informative but never dull. Banerjee and Duflo are the teachers you always wished for but never had, and this book is an essential guide for the great policy debates of our times.”―Raghuram Rajan, Katherine Dusak Miller Distinguished Service Professor of Finance at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business
In a world grappling with economic uncertainties, two renowned economists offer a refreshing perspective on some of the most pressing issues of our time. This groundbreaking work challenges conventional wisdom and provides innovative solutions to global problems like immigration, inequality, and slow economic growth. By combining rigorous research with real-world examples, the authors present a compelling case for evidence-based policymaking. Their approach is not just about understanding the economy, but about using economic tools to build a better society.
Good Economics for Hard Times is primarily aimed at policymakers, economists, and students of economics who are looking for fresh perspectives on global economic challenges. However, its accessible writing style and real-world examples make it equally appealing to general readers interested in understanding the complexities of modern economies. The book strikes a balance between academic rigor and practical relevance, making it suitable for both experts and novices in the field. While some economic concepts might be challenging for complete beginners, the authors’ clear explanations and relatable anecdotes help bridge the gap, making complex ideas digestible for a wide audience.
In a world where economic uncertainties loom large, two Nobel laureates step forward with a beacon of hope. Abhijit V. Banerjee and Esther Duflo’s Good Economics for Hard Times is not just another economics book – it’s a call to arms, challenging us to rethink our approach to global issues. Picture a doctor diagnosing a patient with a complex illness. Instead of relying on outdated textbooks or unproven remedies, they meticulously examine the evidence, run tests, and tailor a treatment plan. This is precisely what Banerjee and Duflo do for our ailing global economy.
The authors take us on a journey through the thorniest economic issues of our time – immigration, inequality, globalization, and technological disruption. But unlike many economists who rely on abstract models and assumptions, Banerjee and Duflo ground their analysis in rigorous empirical research and real-world experiments. They show us that the conventional wisdom often falls short, and that solutions to our most pressing problems may lie in unexpected places.
One of the book’s most compelling arguments is that economics, when done right, can be a powerful force for good. The authors dismantle popular misconceptions about topics like immigration, showing that fears of job losses and wage depression are often unfounded. They argue that well-designed policies can create win-win situations, benefiting both immigrants and native workers. This approach of questioning assumptions and looking at hard data runs throughout the book, offering fresh perspectives on issues we thought we understood.
Good Economics for Hard Times doesn’t just identify problems; it offers solutions. Banerjee and Duflo propose innovative policy ideas, from universal basic income to new approaches to trade policy. They make a compelling case for evidence-based policymaking, arguing that small-scale experiments can yield valuable insights for tackling large-scale problems. The authors’ ability to translate complex economic concepts into accessible language makes these ideas not just understandable, but actionable.
Readers of this book will come away with a new toolkit for understanding the world around them. They’ll learn how to critically evaluate economic claims, understand the limitations of traditional economic models, and appreciate the power of empirical evidence. More importantly, they’ll gain a renewed sense of optimism – a belief that with careful analysis and innovative thinking, we can indeed find good economics for these hard times.
The central thesis of Good Economics for Hard Times is that evidence-based economics, rooted in rigorous research and real-world experiments, can provide effective solutions to our most pressing global challenges. Banerjee and Duflo argue that by questioning conventional wisdom and carefully examining data, we can develop policies that improve lives and create more equitable societies.
The authors emphasize that good economics is not about adhering to ideological positions or simplistic models. Instead, it’s about being open to evidence, even when it contradicts our preconceptions. They show how this approach can lead to surprising insights – for example, that immigration often boosts rather than harms local economies, or that trade policies need to be more nuanced than simply “free trade” or “protectionism.”
The significance of Good Economics for Hard Times lies in its potential to reshape how we approach economic policy and global challenges. By bridging the gap between academic research and practical policymaking, Banerjee and Duflo offer a roadmap for evidence-based decision-making that could have far-reaching implications.
The book has garnered widespread acclaim for its fresh perspective and rigorous approach. It won the Financial Times and McKinsey Business Book of the Year Award in 2019, with judges praising its timeliness and accessibility. The award of the Nobel Prize in Economics to Banerjee and Duflo (along with Michael Kremer) in the same year further underscored the importance of their work in development economics and their approach to fighting global poverty.
However, the book is not without controversy. Some critics argue that the authors’ focus on randomized controlled trials as a gold standard for economic research may overlook important systemic factors. Others suggest that their policy recommendations, while innovative, may be challenging to implement on a large scale.
Despite these debates, Good Economics for Hard Times has undeniably enriched the public discourse on economic policy. It has brought complex economic ideas into the mainstream, encouraging policymakers and citizens alike to demand more evidence-based approaches to solving global problems. In a time of increasing polarization and economic uncertainty, the book’s message of pragmatic, research-driven policymaking offers a much-needed middle ground and a path forward for addressing our most pressing economic challenges.
We find Good Economics for Hard Times to be a compelling and timely contribution to the field of economics and public policy. Banerjee and Duflo have crafted a work that successfully bridges the gap between academic rigor and accessible communication, offering valuable insights into some of the most pressing economic challenges of our time.
The book’s greatest strength lies in its unwavering commitment to evidence-based analysis. By grounding their arguments in rigorous research and real-world experiments, the authors provide a refreshing antidote to ideologically driven economic debates. Their willingness to challenge conventional wisdom and offer nuanced perspectives on contentious issues like immigration, trade, and inequality is particularly commendable.
We appreciate the authors’ global perspective, which draws insights from a wide range of countries and contexts. This broad view allows readers to understand how economic principles play out in different settings and helps identify universal truths about human behavior and economic systems. The interdisciplinary approach, incorporating insights from psychology, sociology, and other fields, adds depth to the analysis and provides a more holistic understanding of complex economic phenomena.
The book’s focus on practical policy recommendations is another significant strength. Rather than simply identifying problems, Banerjee and Duflo offer concrete, innovative solutions grounded in evidence. This makes the book valuable not just as an academic work, but as a guide for real-world policymaking.
However, we also recognize some limitations in the book’s approach. The authors’ reliance on randomized controlled trials, while generally a strength, may sometimes lead to an underappreciation of other research methodologies and broader systemic factors. Additionally, the book could have benefited from a more thorough discussion of the practical challenges involved in implementing its policy recommendations.
We also note that the book’s focus on government-led solutions may underestimate the potential of market-driven or community-led initiatives to address economic issues. A more in-depth exploration of technological disruption and environmental sustainability would have further strengthened the book’s analysis of future economic challenges.
Our Recommendation
Despite these limitations, we wholeheartedly recommend Good Economics for Hard Times to a wide range of readers. For policymakers and economists, the book offers fresh perspectives and evidence-based approaches to addressing pressing economic issues. Business leaders and entrepreneurs will find valuable insights into global economic trends and their potential impacts. Students of economics and related fields will benefit from the book’s clear explanations of complex concepts and its emphasis on rigorous, real-world research.
For general readers interested in understanding the economic forces shaping our world, we believe this book is an excellent choice. Its accessible writing style, compelling examples, and global perspective make it an engaging and informative read. While it may challenge some commonly held beliefs, we believe it will leave readers with a more nuanced, evidence-based understanding of economic issues and a renewed sense of the potential for thoughtful policies to make a positive difference in people’s lives.
The essence of Good Economics for Hard Times lies in its commitment to evidence-based economics and policy-making. Banerjee and Duflo argue that many of our preconceptions about how economies work are flawed, and that by carefully examining data and conducting rigorous experiments, we can develop more effective solutions to global challenges. They emphasize the importance of questioning conventional wisdom and being open to surprising results. This approach leads them to challenge many commonly held beliefs about economics and propose innovative policy solutions.
One key topic the authors explore is immigration. They argue that contrary to popular belief, immigration often has positive effects on host economies. By examining various studies and data, they show that immigrants frequently complement rather than compete with native workers, often taking jobs that locals are unwilling to do. They also demonstrate that immigrants can stimulate economic growth by bringing new skills and perspectives. The authors use this as an example of how evidence-based thinking can lead to counterintuitive but important insights.
Another crucial element of the book is its examination of inequality. Banerjee and Duflo argue that rising inequality is not an inevitable consequence of economic growth or globalization, but rather the result of specific policy choices. They explore how factors such as technological change, market concentration, and tax policies contribute to inequality. The authors propose that addressing inequality requires a multifaceted approach, including progressive taxation, investment in education and skills training, and policies to promote competition and reduce market concentration.
Trade policy is another significant topic in the book. The authors challenge the simplistic dichotomy between free trade and protectionism, arguing for a more nuanced approach. They show that while trade can bring benefits, it can also lead to significant disruptions in local labor markets. Banerjee and Duflo propose that effective trade policy should include measures to support workers and communities affected by trade-related job losses. They suggest ideas such as wage insurance and relocation assistance to help mitigate the negative impacts of trade.
The role of economics in addressing climate change is also a key focus. The authors argue that traditional economic models often underestimate the risks and costs of climate change. They advocate for a more comprehensive approach that takes into account long-term risks and uncertainties. Banerjee and Duflo propose innovative policy solutions, such as carbon pricing combined with redistributive measures to ensure that the costs of addressing climate change are fairly shared.
Lastly, the book explores the concept of economic growth and its limitations. The authors question whether GDP growth should be the primary goal of economic policy, suggesting that measures of well-being and quality of life might be more meaningful. They discuss how factors such as social connections, health, and environmental quality contribute to overall welfare. This perspective leads them to propose policies that focus on improving people’s lives directly, rather than assuming that economic growth will automatically lead to better outcomes.
The Mariel Boatlift To illustrate their points about immigration, Banerjee and Duflo discuss the Mariel Boatlift of 1980, when approximately 125,000 Cubans arrived in Miami over a six-month period. Contrary to fears of economic disruption, studies showed that this sudden influx had little negative impact on wages or employment of local workers. The authors use this case to demonstrate how real-world evidence can contradict common assumptions about the economic effects of immigration.
The Indian IT Boom When discussing inequality and the impact of technological change, the authors examine the IT boom in India. They describe how the rapid growth of the IT sector led to increased demand for English-speaking, college-educated workers, driving up their wages relative to other workers. This example illustrates how technological changes can contribute to wage inequality, but also how they can create new opportunities for economic growth and development.
The China Shock To explore the complexities of trade policy, Banerjee and Duflo discuss the “China Shock” – the rapid increase in imports from China to the United States in the early 2000s. They describe how this led to significant job losses in certain US manufacturing sectors and regions. The authors use this case to argue for more nuanced trade policies that consider the distributional impacts of trade and provide support for affected workers and communities.
Randomized Controlled Trials in Development Economics Throughout the book, the authors draw on their experience with randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in development economics. For example, they discuss an RCT they conducted in India that tested different approaches to improving immunization rates. By randomly assigning villages to different interventions, they were able to identify which strategies were most effective. This example illustrates the authors’ commitment to evidence-based policy-making and their belief in the power of experimental methods to inform economic policy.
Universal Basic Income in Kenya When discussing potential solutions to poverty and inequality, the authors describe a large-scale experiment with universal basic income (UBI) in Kenya. This long-term study, conducted by the charity GiveDirectly, involves providing regular cash transfers to thousands of individuals over a 12-year period. Banerjee and Duflo use this ongoing experiment to explore the potential benefits and challenges of UBI as a policy tool, emphasizing the importance of rigorous, long-term studies in evaluating new policy ideas.
Carbon Pricing in British Columbia To illustrate potential approaches to addressing climate change, the authors discuss the carbon pricing system implemented in British Columbia, Canada. They describe how this policy, which includes both a carbon tax and rebates to households, has led to reduced emissions without significant negative economic impacts. This example is used to argue for the potential of well-designed environmental policies to address climate change while minimizing economic disruption.
Evidence-Based Policy Making is Crucial
One of the most significant insights from the book is the importance of evidence-based policy making. Banerjee and Duflo argue that many economic policies are based on outdated theories or untested assumptions, leading to ineffective or even harmful outcomes. They advocate for a more scientific approach to economics, where policies are rigorously tested before being implemented on a large scale. This can be applied by conducting randomized controlled trials (RCTs) to evaluate policy interventions. For example, before rolling out a new education program nationwide, policymakers could test it in a few randomly selected schools and compare the results with control groups. This approach allows for fine-tuning of policies based on real-world evidence, potentially saving resources and improving outcomes. Businesses can also adopt this method by A/B testing new strategies or products on a small scale before full implementation.
Immigration Often Benefits Host Economies
Contrary to popular belief, Banerjee and Duflo present compelling evidence that immigration often has positive effects on host economies. They show that immigrants frequently fill labor shortages, contribute to innovation, and stimulate economic growth. This insight can be applied in several ways. Policymakers could design immigration policies that target specific skill shortages in the economy, rather than imposing blanket restrictions. Businesses could actively recruit international talent to drive innovation and expand into new markets. Cities and regions could develop programs to attract and integrate immigrants, recognizing them as a potential source of economic dynamism. For example, a city could create a “welcome center” that provides language classes, job placement services, and cultural integration programs for new immigrants, helping them become productive members of the community more quickly.
Addressing Inequality Requires Multifaceted Approaches
The book offers valuable insights into the complex nature of inequality and the need for multifaceted solutions. Banerjee and Duflo argue that rising inequality is not an inevitable consequence of economic growth but the result of specific policy choices. To address this, they suggest a combination of progressive taxation, investment in education and skills training, and policies to promote competition and reduce market concentration. Applying this insight could involve implementing a more progressive tax system that redistributes wealth more effectively. Governments could invest heavily in early childhood education and vocational training programs to improve long-term economic mobility. Antitrust authorities could more aggressively break up monopolies and oligopolies to promote competition and reduce the concentration of wealth. For instance, a government could create a comprehensive “Equality of Opportunity” program that combines progressive taxation with targeted investments in education, healthcare, and job training in disadvantaged communities.
Trade Policy Needs Nuance and Support for Affected Workers
Banerjee and Duflo challenge the simplistic dichotomy between free trade and protectionism, arguing for a more nuanced approach to trade policy. They recognize that while trade can bring overall benefits, it can also lead to significant disruptions in local labor markets. To apply this insight, policymakers could design trade agreements that include provisions for worker retraining and relocation assistance. They could implement wage insurance programs that temporarily subsidize workers who lose their jobs due to trade and have to take lower-paying positions. Local governments in areas heavily affected by trade-related job losses could create economic diversification programs to attract new industries. For example, a state government could establish a “Trade Adjustment Assistance Plus” program that combines federal trade adjustment assistance with state-funded job retraining, relocation support, and incentives for businesses to hire affected workers.
Climate Change Requires Innovative Economic Solutions
The book provides important insights into the economic challenges posed by climate change and the need for innovative solutions. Banerjee and Duflo argue that traditional economic models often underestimate the risks and costs of climate change, and they advocate for a more comprehensive approach. To apply this insight, governments could implement carbon pricing systems that accurately reflect the long-term costs of carbon emissions. These could be designed with rebates or dividends to low-income households to ensure fairness. Businesses could adopt internal carbon pricing to guide investment decisions. Cities could invest in climate resilience infrastructure, recognizing the long-term economic benefits of adaptation. For instance, a country could implement a “Carbon Fee and Dividend” policy, where a fee is placed on carbon emissions and the revenue is redistributed equally to all citizens, combining climate action with poverty reduction.
GDP Growth Should Not Be the Only Measure of Progress
Banerjee and Duflo offer a critical insight by questioning whether GDP growth should be the primary goal of economic policy. They suggest that measures of well-being and quality of life might be more meaningful. To apply this insight, governments could develop and track alternative indicators of progress that include factors such as health outcomes, education levels, environmental quality, and subjective well-being. Policymakers could use these broader measures to guide decision-making and evaluate the success of policies. Businesses could adopt triple bottom line accounting, considering their impact on people and the planet alongside profits. For example, a country could create a “National Well-being Index” that combines economic indicators with measures of health, education, environmental quality, and life satisfaction, and use this index to guide policy decisions and measure progress over time.
Small-Scale Experiments Can Yield Big Insights
A key insight from the book is the power of small-scale experiments to inform large-scale policy decisions. Banerjee and Duflo demonstrate how carefully designed studies can yield valuable insights into complex economic issues. To apply this, governments could establish “policy labs” that conduct small-scale experiments before rolling out major policy initiatives. Businesses could use A/B testing more extensively, not just for marketing but for organizational policies and practices. Non-profit organizations could pilot different approaches to service delivery and rigorously evaluate the results before scaling up. For instance, a city government could create an “Urban Innovation Lab” that tests different approaches to issues like traffic management, waste reduction, or homelessness prevention on a neighborhood level before citywide implementation.
Social Norms and Behavior Play a Crucial Role in Economic Outcomes
Banerjee and Duflo highlight the often-overlooked role of social norms and behavior in shaping economic outcomes. They show how factors like trust, social cohesion, and cultural attitudes can significantly impact economic performance. To apply this insight, policymakers could design interventions that take into account local social norms and work to shift harmful norms over time. Businesses could invest in building corporate cultures that foster trust and cooperation. Educational institutions could incorporate social-emotional learning alongside traditional academic subjects. For example, a government anti-corruption campaign could go beyond punitive measures to include efforts to shift social norms around corruption, perhaps through public education campaigns, school programs, and high-profile integrity awards for public officials and businesses.
Rigorous Evidence-Based Approach One of the most significant strengths of Good Economics for Hard Times is its unwavering commitment to evidence-based analysis. Banerjee and Duflo consistently ground their arguments in rigorous research, often drawing from randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and other empirical studies. This approach lends credibility to their conclusions and sets a high standard for economic discourse. For instance, when discussing the effects of immigration on local labor markets, the authors don’t rely on theoretical models or anecdotal evidence. Instead, they meticulously examine data from various studies, including natural experiments like the Mariel Boatlift. This dedication to empirical evidence allows readers to trust the authors’ conclusions and provides a model for how economic analysis should be conducted.
Challenging Conventional Wisdom The book excels in its willingness to challenge long-held economic beliefs and popular misconceptions. Banerjee and Duflo don’t shy away from tackling contentious issues like immigration, trade, and inequality. They systematically dismantle oversimplified narratives and present nuanced, data-driven perspectives. For example, their analysis of trade policy goes beyond the typical free trade versus protectionism debate, offering a more complex view that acknowledges both the benefits and drawbacks of international trade. This willingness to question established thinking and offer fresh perspectives is refreshing and intellectually stimulating, encouraging readers to think critically about economic issues.
Accessible Writing Style Despite dealing with complex economic concepts, Banerjee and Duflo manage to present their ideas in a clear, engaging manner that’s accessible to a wide audience. They skillfully balance academic rigor with readability, using relatable examples and analogies to illustrate abstract concepts. For instance, when explaining the concept of economic mobility, they use the metaphor of a “sticky floor” and a “glass ceiling,” making the idea more tangible for non-expert readers. This accessibility is crucial, as it allows the book to reach beyond academic circles and engage with policymakers, business leaders, and general readers interested in understanding economic issues.
Practical Policy Recommendations The book doesn’t just identify problems; it offers concrete, innovative policy solutions. Banerjee and Duflo provide actionable recommendations for addressing issues like inequality, climate change, and economic growth. These suggestions are grounded in evidence and often challenge conventional policy approaches. For example, their proposal for a universal ultra-basic income (UUBI) in developing countries is both novel and well-reasoned, backed by data from various cash transfer programs. This focus on practical solutions makes the book valuable not just as an academic work, but as a guide for real-world policy-making.
Global Perspective Good Economics for Hard Times stands out for its truly global perspective on economic issues. While many economics books focus primarily on developed economies, Banerjee and Duflo draw insights from a wide range of countries and contexts. They seamlessly weave together examples from the United States, India, Kenya, and many other nations, providing a comprehensive view of global economic challenges. This broad perspective allows readers to understand how economic principles play out in different contexts and helps to identify universal truths about human behavior and economic systems.
Interdisciplinary Approach The authors’ willingness to incorporate insights from other disciplines strengthens their analysis. They draw not only from economics but also from psychology, sociology, and political science to provide a more holistic understanding of economic phenomena. For instance, their discussion of the importance of dignity in work and the psychological impacts of job loss goes beyond traditional economic analysis, incorporating insights from psychology and sociology. This interdisciplinary approach provides a richer, more nuanced understanding of complex economic issues.
Limited Discussion of Implementation Challenges While the book offers many innovative policy recommendations, it sometimes falls short in addressing the practical challenges of implementing these policies. The authors’ proposals, such as universal basic income or new approaches to trade policy, are often compelling in theory but may face significant political and logistical hurdles in practice. A more in-depth discussion of these implementation challenges and potential strategies to overcome them would have strengthened the book’s practical value for policymakers.
Potential Overreliance on Randomized Controlled Trials While the authors’ emphasis on evidence-based policy is commendable, there’s a risk of overreliance on randomized controlled trials (RCTs) as the gold standard for economic research. RCTs have limitations, particularly when it comes to studying large-scale economic phenomena or long-term effects. The book could have benefited from a more explicit discussion of the limitations of RCTs and a broader consideration of other research methodologies.
Limited Engagement with Opposing Views Although Banerjee and Duflo challenge many conventional economic ideas, they sometimes don’t fully engage with opposing viewpoints. In some cases, alternative explanations or critiques of their positions are given relatively brief treatment. A more thorough discussion of competing ideas and a point-by-point refutation of major criticisms would have strengthened their arguments and provided readers with a more comprehensive understanding of the debates surrounding these issues.
Lack of Historical Context While the book provides an excellent analysis of current economic challenges, it sometimes lacks historical depth. A more thorough examination of how current economic issues have evolved over time could have provided valuable context and insights. For instance, the discussion of inequality could have benefited from a more detailed historical analysis of how wealth distribution has changed over the past century in different parts of the world. This historical perspective would have helped readers understand the long-term trends and cycles that shape our current economic landscape.
Overemphasis on Government Solutions
One potential blind spot in Good Economics for Hard Times is its tendency to focus primarily on government-led solutions to economic challenges. While the authors’ policy recommendations are often innovative and well-reasoned, they may underestimate the potential of market-driven or community-led initiatives to address economic issues. This approach could lead readers to overlook the importance of entrepreneurship, innovation, and civil society in driving economic progress. For a more balanced perspective, readers might consider complementing Banerjee and Duflo’s work with books that explore market-based solutions to social and economic problems. For instance, Muhammad Yunus’s Creating a World Without Poverty: Social Business and the Future of Capitalism offers insights into how social businesses can address poverty and other social issues. Similarly, William Easterly’s The White Man’s Burden: Why the West’s Efforts to Aid the Rest Have Done So Much Ill and So Little Good provides a critical perspective on top-down development approaches and argues for more localized, market-driven solutions.
Limited Discussion of Technological Disruption
While Good Economics for Hard Times touches on the impact of technology on labor markets and inequality, it may not fully capture the scale and pace of technological disruption facing the global economy. The book’s analysis and policy recommendations could be seen as underestimating the potential for artificial intelligence, automation, and other emerging technologies to radically reshape economic structures and labor markets in the near future. This blind spot could lead to an underestimation of the urgency and scale of policy responses needed to address technological unemployment and skills obsolescence. Readers interested in exploring these issues more deeply might turn to works like Erik Brynjolfsson and Andrew McAfee’s The Second Machine Age: Work, Progress, and Prosperity in a Time of Brilliant Technologies, which offers a more detailed examination of how digital technologies are transforming the economy. Additionally, Martin Ford’s Rise of the Robots: Technology and the Threat of a Jobless Future provides a sobering look at the potential impacts of automation on employment and economic structures.
Underexploration of Environmental Sustainability
While Banerjee and Duflo address climate change and environmental issues, their treatment of these topics may not fully capture the urgency and systemic nature of environmental challenges facing the global economy. The book’s economic analysis and policy recommendations could be seen as insufficiently integrating principles of ecological economics and sustainability. This blind spot could lead to an underestimation of the fundamental changes needed in economic systems to address environmental degradation and ensure long-term sustainability. For a deeper exploration of these issues, readers might consider works like Kate Raworth’s Doughnut Economics: Seven Ways to Think Like a 21st-Century Economist, which offers a model for balancing social and planetary boundaries in economic thinking. Herman Daly’s Beyond Growth: The Economics of Sustainable Development also provides valuable insights into how economic systems can be redesigned to operate within ecological limits.
Limited Focus on Financial Systems and Monetary Policy
Good Economics for Hard Times provides valuable insights into many aspects of economic policy, but it may not give sufficient attention to the role of financial systems and monetary policy in shaping economic outcomes. The book’s analysis could be seen as underexploring how banking systems, financial regulations, and central bank policies influence economic stability, inequality, and growth. This blind spot could lead to an incomplete understanding of the levers available for addressing economic challenges. Readers seeking a more comprehensive understanding of these issues might turn to works like Adair Turner’s Between Debt and the Devil: Money, Credit, and Fixing Global Finance, which offers a critical examination of the role of credit creation in modern economies. Additionally, Yanis Varoufakis’s The Global Minotaur: America, Europe and the Future of the Global Economy provides a thought-provoking analysis of global financial imbalances and their impact on economic stability.
Underemphasis on Cultural and Institutional Factors
While Banerjee and Duflo acknowledge the importance of social norms and behavior in economic outcomes, their analysis may not fully capture the deep influence of cultural and institutional factors on economic development. The book’s policy recommendations could be seen as insufficiently accounting for how cultural values, historical legacies, and institutional structures shape economic behaviors and outcomes in different contexts. This blind spot could lead to an oversimplification of the challenges involved in implementing economic reforms across diverse cultural and institutional settings. For a deeper exploration of these issues, readers might consider Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson’s Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty, which offers a comprehensive analysis of how institutions shape economic outcomes. Additionally, David Landes’s The Wealth and Poverty of Nations: Why Some Are So Rich and Some So Poor provides valuable insights into the historical and cultural factors that have influenced economic development across different regions of the world.
Poor Economics by Abhijit V. Banerjee and Esther Duflo
Good Economics for Hard Times can be seen as a natural evolution of the authors’ earlier work, Poor Economics. While both books share a commitment to evidence-based policymaking and a focus on real-world impacts, they differ in scope and target audience. Poor Economics primarily focuses on poverty in developing countries, offering micro-level insights into the economic lives of the poor. In contrast, Good Economics for Hard Times broadens its scope to address global economic challenges, including issues faced by developed economies. The later book also engages more directly with current political debates, offering policy recommendations for pressing issues like immigration and inequality. Both books showcase the authors’ rigorous empirical approach, but Good Economics for Hard Times demonstrates a more ambitious attempt to reshape mainstream economic thinking and policy debates.
Capital in the Twenty-First Century by Thomas Piketty
While both books address inequality, Piketty’s Capital in the Twenty-First Century and Good Economics for Hard Times differ significantly in their approach and conclusions. Piketty’s work is a sweeping historical analysis of wealth and income inequality, arguing that the rate of return on capital tends to exceed the rate of economic growth, leading to increasing inequality over time. Banerjee and Duflo, on the other hand, focus more on current policy debates and offer a more optimistic view of the potential for policy interventions to address inequality. While Piketty’s work is more theoretical and macro-focused, Banerjee and Duflo ground their analysis in micro-level studies and randomized controlled trials. Both books have been influential, but Good Economics for Hard Times offers more immediate, practical policy recommendations.
The Price of Inequality by Joseph E. Stiglitz
Stiglitz’s The Price of Inequality shares some common ground with Good Economics for Hard Times in its critique of rising inequality and its negative societal impacts. However, Stiglitz’s book places more emphasis on the role of political factors in driving economic inequality, arguing that the U.S. economic system has been rigged in favor of the wealthy. While Banerjee and Duflo acknowledge political factors, their analysis focuses more on the complex interplay of economic forces and human behavior. Stiglitz’s policy recommendations tend to be more radical, calling for fundamental changes to economic and political systems. In contrast, Banerjee and Duflo offer more incremental, evidence-based policy suggestions. Both books contribute valuable insights to the inequality debate, but Good Economics for Hard Times may be seen as offering a more globally applicable and empirically grounded approach.
Factfulness by Hans Rosling, Ola Rosling, and Anna Rosling Rönnlund
While not strictly an economics book, Factfulness shares with Good Economics for Hard Times a commitment to challenging popular misconceptions with data-driven analysis. Both books aim to provide a more nuanced, fact-based understanding of global issues. However, Factfulness focuses more broadly on global development trends, arguing that the world is in a better state than most people believe. Banerjee and Duflo, while also challenging some pessimistic narratives, focus more specifically on economic issues and offer more detailed policy prescriptions. Factfulness is perhaps more accessible to a general audience, while Good Economics for Hard Times offers deeper economic insights. Both books contribute to more informed public discourse on global issues, but Banerjee and Duflo’s work provides more specific guidance for economic policymaking.
The Undercover Economist by Tim Harford
Both The Undercover Economist and Good Economics for Hard Times aim to make economic concepts accessible to a general audience. However, they differ significantly in their approach and focus. Harford’s book uses everyday examples to explain basic economic principles, focusing on how economics can help understand daily life and business decisions. Banerjee and Duflo, while also using relatable examples, focus more on policy-relevant economic research and its implications for addressing major global challenges. The Undercover Economist is perhaps more suitable as an introduction to economic thinking for beginners, while Good Economics for Hard Times offers a more advanced, policy-oriented perspective. Both books contribute to economic literacy, but Banerjee and Duflo’s work is more directly engaged with current policy debates and cutting-edge economic research.
Develop Critical Thinking Skills To apply the evidence-based approach championed by Banerjee and Duflo, start by honing your critical thinking skills. Begin by questioning your assumptions about economic issues. When you encounter economic news or policy proposals, ask yourself: What evidence supports this claim? Are there alternative explanations? Is this a causal relationship or just a correlation? Practice looking for primary sources and peer-reviewed studies rather than relying solely on media interpretations. Consider taking an online course in statistics or research methods to better understand and evaluate economic studies. Engage in discussions with people who have different viewpoints, focusing on evidence-based arguments rather than ideological positions.
Embrace a Global Perspective Expand your understanding of global economic issues. Start by regularly reading international news sources from different regions of the world. Follow economic developments in countries at various stages of development, not just in your home country or other developed economies. Consider learning a new language to gain deeper insights into different cultures and economies. If possible, travel to countries with different economic systems or levels of development to gain firsthand experience. Engage with people from diverse backgrounds in your community to understand their economic experiences and perspectives.
Prioritize Continuous Learning Stay updated on economic research and policy debates. Subscribe to reputable economics blogs or podcasts that discuss current research and policy issues. Consider taking online courses in economics or related fields through platforms like Coursera or edX. Read a diverse range of economics books, including those that challenge your current beliefs. Attend public lectures or webinars by economists and policymakers. Join or form a book club focused on economics and public policy books to discuss and debate ideas with others.
Engage in Evidence-Based Decision Making Apply the book’s emphasis on evidence to your personal and professional decision-making. When faced with important decisions, resist the urge to rely solely on intuition or conventional wisdom. Instead, seek out relevant data and research. For financial decisions, look at historical trends and expert analyses rather than following market hype. In your professional life, advocate for data-driven decision-making processes. Propose pilot projects or A/B testing for new initiatives to gather evidence before full implementation. Learn basic data analysis skills to interpret and present evidence effectively.
Contribute to Local Policy Discussions Get involved in local policy discussions, applying the nuanced understanding of economic issues you’ve gained from the book. Attend town hall meetings or city council sessions. When economic issues are discussed, ask questions about the evidence behind proposed policies. Advocate for pilot programs and rigorous evaluation of local initiatives. Consider joining local committees or advisory boards where you can contribute your evidence-based perspective. Write letters to your local representatives or op-eds for local newspapers, focusing on evidence-based arguments for or against specific policies.
Rethink Your Approach to Charitable Giving Apply the book’s insights on effective poverty alleviation to your charitable giving. Research the effectiveness of different charitable organizations using resources like GiveWell, which evaluates charities based on rigorous evidence. Consider directing your donations towards organizations that conduct or fund randomized controlled trials to test the effectiveness of their interventions. Look for charities that are transparent about their methods and results, and that are willing to change their approach based on evidence. Consider supporting direct cash transfer programs, which the book highlights as often being highly effective.
Advocate for Evidence-Based Workplace Policies In your professional life, advocate for evidence-based policies and practices. If you’re in a leadership position, propose conducting small-scale experiments or pilot programs before implementing major changes. Encourage your organization to collect and analyze data on the outcomes of various initiatives. Advocate for diversity and inclusion initiatives, citing research on the economic benefits of diverse workforces. Push for fair wage policies, using evidence on the impacts of wage increases on productivity and employee retention. Suggest implementation of skills training programs, drawing on research about effective adult learning and skill development.
Reassess Your Views on Immigration Challenge your preconceptions about immigration by seeking out empirical research on its economic impacts. Look for studies on how immigration affects local labor markets, innovation, and economic growth in various contexts. Engage with immigrants in your community to understand their experiences and contributions. If you’re an employer, consider the potential benefits of hiring immigrants, including their diverse perspectives and skills. In political discussions or voting decisions, advocate for immigration policies based on economic evidence rather than fear or stereotypes.
Adopt a Nuanced View on Trade Develop a more sophisticated understanding of trade issues. Research the specific impacts of trade policies on different industries and communities. Look beyond simplistic “free trade vs. protectionism” debates to understand the complexities of modern global trade. If you’re in business, consider how trade policies affect your supply chains and markets, and develop strategies to adapt to changing trade environments. As a consumer, research the global supply chains of products you buy and consider the broader economic impacts of your purchasing decisions.
Broaden Your Measure of Economic Success Expand your perspective on what constitutes economic success beyond simple measures like GDP or stock market performance. Start tracking a broader range of economic indicators, including measures of inequality, environmental sustainability, and quality of life. In your personal life, consider defining success more holistically, incorporating factors like work-life balance, community engagement, and personal growth alongside financial goals. In your professional life, advocate for broader measures of organizational success that include employee well-being, community impact, and long-term sustainability.
Engage in Lifelong Skill Development Recognize the importance of continual skill development in a changing economy. Regularly assess your skills and identify areas for improvement or new skills to develop. Take advantage of online learning platforms, professional development courses, or local educational programs to continuously update your skills. Consider learning coding or data analysis skills, which are increasingly valuable across many fields. Stay informed about emerging technologies and their potential impacts on your industry. Be proactive in seeking out new responsibilities or projects at work that will help you develop new skills.
Promote Financial Literacy Apply the book’s insights on economic behavior to improve your own financial literacy and help others do the same. Learn about behavioral economics and how it affects financial decision-making. Use this knowledge to develop better saving and investing habits. Consider automating your savings and investment contributions to overcome cognitive biases. If you have children, teach them about money management from an early age, using evidence-based approaches. In your community, consider volunteering to teach financial literacy classes or mentoring others on financial management.
Support Sustainable Economic Practices Incorporate the book’s long-term perspective on economic challenges into your daily life. Research the environmental impacts of your consumption habits and look for ways to reduce your carbon footprint. Consider switching to a bank or investment fund that prioritizes sustainable and ethical investments. In your professional life, advocate for sustainable business practices, citing evidence on their long-term economic benefits. Support policies aimed at addressing climate change, understanding them as economic as well as environmental issues.
Embrace Evidence-Based Decision Making
Businesses can significantly benefit from adopting the evidence-based approach advocated in Good Economics for Hard Times. This involves moving away from decision-making based solely on intuition or tradition, and instead relying on rigorous data analysis and experimental methods. Companies should implement a culture of testing hypotheses, conducting pilot studies, and making decisions based on empirical evidence. This approach can lead to more effective strategies, improved resource allocation, and better overall performance.
However, implementing evidence-based decision-making can face several challenges. Many organizations have entrenched ways of making decisions that may be resistant to change. There might be a lack of expertise in data analysis and experimental design within the company. Additionally, conducting rigorous studies and experiments can be time-consuming and potentially costly, which may deter some businesses from adopting this approach.
To overcome these challenges, companies can start by investing in training programs to develop data analysis and experimental design skills among their employees. They can also create cross-functional teams that include both domain experts and data scientists to collaborate on decision-making processes. Starting with small-scale pilot projects can help demonstrate the value of evidence-based approaches without requiring a massive initial investment. Gradually, as the benefits become apparent, the approach can be scaled up across the organization.
Adopt a Global Perspective
In an increasingly interconnected world economy, businesses can benefit from adopting the global perspective emphasized in Banerjee and Duflo’s work. This involves looking beyond local or national markets to understand global economic trends, diverse consumer behaviors, and international business practices. Companies should strive to diversify their workforce, consider expanding into new markets, and adapt their products or services to suit different cultural contexts.
However, adopting a truly global perspective can be challenging. It requires significant resources to research and understand diverse markets. There may be language barriers, cultural misunderstandings, or legal and regulatory hurdles when operating across borders. Additionally, some employees or stakeholders may resist internationalization efforts due to perceived risks or a preference for focusing on familiar markets.
To address these challenges, businesses can start by fostering a culture of global awareness within the organization. This could involve offering language classes, cultural sensitivity training, and international exchange programs for employees. Companies can also leverage partnerships with local firms when entering new markets to gain insights and navigate local complexities. Gradual expansion, starting with markets that are culturally or economically similar, can help build experience and confidence in operating globally.
Prioritize Long-Term Sustainability
Banerjee and Duflo’s work emphasizes the importance of considering long-term impacts and sustainability in economic decision-making. Businesses can apply this principle by prioritizing sustainable practices, considering their environmental and social impacts, and focusing on long-term value creation rather than short-term profits. This could involve investing in renewable energy, implementing circular economy principles, or developing products and services that address social or environmental challenges.
However, prioritizing long-term sustainability can be challenging in a business environment often focused on quarterly results and short-term shareholder value. Sustainable practices may require significant upfront investments that don’t show immediate financial returns. There may also be a lack of expertise within the organization on how to implement sustainable practices effectively.
To overcome these obstacles, companies can start by educating their board members, executives, and shareholders about the long-term benefits of sustainable practices, including improved risk management, enhanced reputation, and potential cost savings over time. They can set clear, measurable sustainability goals and integrate them into their overall business strategy and performance metrics. Partnering with environmental organizations or sustainability consultants can provide expertise and credibility to these efforts. Companies can also explore green financing options to fund sustainability initiatives.
Address Inequality Within the Organization
Good Economics for Hard Times provides insights into the causes and consequences of inequality, which businesses can apply to their own organizational structures. Companies should examine their wage policies, promotion practices, and overall organizational structure to identify and address potential sources of inequality. This could involve implementing more transparent and equitable pay structures, providing equal opportunities for skill development and career advancement, and fostering a more inclusive workplace culture.
However, addressing inequality within an organization can be challenging. There may be resistance from those who benefit from the current system. Changing established salary structures or promotion practices can be complex and potentially disruptive. There might also be concerns about the cost implications of raising wages for lower-paid employees.
To address these challenges, companies can start by conducting a thorough audit of their current practices to identify areas of inequality. They can then develop a phased approach to addressing these issues, starting with the most glaring disparities. Transparent communication about the reasons for changes and their expected benefits can help gain buy-in from employees at all levels. Companies can also consider innovative approaches like profit-sharing schemes or employee ownership programs to align interests across the organization. Investing in training and development programs can help employees at all levels improve their skills and advance their careers, promoting greater equality of opportunity.
Rethink Hiring and Training Practices
The book’s insights on labor markets and skill development can inform how businesses approach hiring and training. Companies should consider looking beyond traditional credentials to identify talent, focusing more on skills and potential rather than formal qualifications. They should also invest in ongoing training and skill development for their workforce to adapt to changing economic conditions and technological advances.
Implementing these changes can face several obstacles. Traditional hiring practices are often deeply ingrained in HR processes and changing them can be met with resistance. There may be concerns about the risk of hiring candidates without traditional credentials. Investing in extensive training programs can be costly, and there may be fears that employees will leave after receiving training, resulting in a loss on investment.
To overcome these challenges, companies can start by piloting new hiring approaches in specific departments or for certain roles, allowing them to test and refine new methods before broader implementation. They can develop partnerships with educational institutions or coding bootcamps to create pipelines of non-traditional talent. For training, companies can implement programs that tie skill development to career progression within the organization, incentivizing employees to stay and apply their new skills. They can also explore innovative training methods like peer-to-peer learning or micro-learning modules that can be more cost-effective and flexible than traditional training programs.
Implement Nuanced Approaches to Globalization
Banerjee and Duflo’s nuanced view on globalization can inform how businesses approach international operations and supply chains. Rather than viewing globalization as uniformly beneficial or harmful, companies should carefully consider the specific impacts of their global activities on different stakeholders. This might involve re-evaluating supply chains to ensure they’re ethical and sustainable, considering the local economic impacts when opening or closing facilities in different countries, and adapting products or services to local needs and contexts.
Implementing such a nuanced approach can be challenging. Global supply chains are often complex and opaque, making it difficult to fully understand and control their impacts. There may be short-term cost implications of choosing more ethical or local suppliers. Adapting products or operations to local contexts can be resource-intensive and may conflict with goals of standardization and efficiency.
To address these challenges, companies can start by conducting comprehensive audits of their global operations and supply chains to identify areas of concern. They can invest in technologies like blockchain to increase supply chain transparency. Forming partnerships with local NGOs or community organizations can provide valuable insights into local contexts and help ensure that global operations have positive local impacts. Companies can also consider creating cross-functional teams responsible for evaluating and optimizing the overall impact of global operations, rather than focusing solely on cost or efficiency metrics.
The Rise of Evidence-Based Policymaking
The core principle of Good Economics for Hard Times aligns strongly with the growing trend of evidence-based policymaking. Governments and organizations are increasingly relying on data and rigorous research to inform decisions. This trend is likely to accelerate in the coming years. We can expect to see more randomized controlled trials in social policy. Data-driven approaches will become standard in areas like education, healthcare, and economic development.
However, challenges remain. There’s a need to balance rapid decision-making with thorough research. Policymakers must also navigate the complexities of interpreting and applying research findings. The book’s emphasis on nuanced understanding of economic issues will be crucial in this context.
Rethinking Measures of Economic Progress
Banerjee and Duflo’s critique of GDP as the primary measure of economic success reflects a broader trend. There’s growing recognition that traditional economic metrics are insufficient. More comprehensive measures of societal well-being are gaining traction. We’re likely to see increased adoption of alternative indicators in the coming years.
These might include measures of inequality, environmental sustainability, and quality of life. Governments may start reporting on a broader range of economic and social indicators. Businesses might adopt more holistic performance metrics. This shift could significantly influence policy priorities and business strategies.
Technological Disruption and the Future of Work
While not a central focus of the book, its insights on labor markets and inequality are highly relevant to ongoing debates about technological disruption. Automation and artificial intelligence are reshaping the job market. The book’s nuanced approach to understanding economic changes will be valuable in navigating these shifts.
We can expect continued debate about the impact of technology on employment. Policy discussions may focus on issues like universal basic income or job retraining programs. Businesses will grapple with ethical considerations around automation. The book’s emphasis on careful analysis and evidence-based approaches will be crucial in these discussions.
Global Cooperation in Economic Policy
The book’s global perspective aligns with a growing recognition of the need for international cooperation on economic issues. Climate change, inequality, and technological disruption are global challenges. They require coordinated responses. We may see increased efforts at global economic governance in the coming years.
This could involve stronger international institutions for economic cooperation. There might be more coordinated approaches to issues like tax policy or labor standards. The book’s insights on the complexities of global economic issues will be valuable in shaping these efforts.
Increasing Focus on Economic Resilience
Recent global shocks like the COVID-19 pandemic have highlighted the importance of economic resilience. This aligns with the book’s emphasis on understanding complex economic systems. We’re likely to see increased focus on building more robust and adaptable economies.
This might involve diversifying supply chains to reduce vulnerabilities. There could be more emphasis on local economic development alongside global integration. Policies aimed at improving economic security for individuals and communities may gain traction. The book’s nuanced approach to understanding economic trade-offs will be valuable in shaping these efforts.
Good Economics for Hard Times has the potential to significantly influence both academic economics and public policy debates in the coming years. By championing an evidence-based approach to economics and policymaking, the book could help shift the field towards more empirical, nuanced analyses of economic issues. This could lead to a greater emphasis on randomized controlled trials and other rigorous research methods in both academic economics and policy evaluation.
The book’s challenge to many conventional economic beliefs could spark renewed debate on issues like immigration, trade, and inequality. By providing evidence that contradicts popular narratives, Banerjee and Duflo’s work might encourage policymakers and the public to question long-held assumptions and consider alternative approaches to addressing economic challenges.
In the realm of development economics, the book’s global perspective and emphasis on context-specific solutions could influence how international organizations and governments approach economic development projects. This could lead to more tailored, evidence-based interventions rather than one-size-fits-all policy prescriptions.
The authors’ accessible writing style and engagement with current policy debates could also help bridge the gap between academic economics and public understanding. This could contribute to more informed public discourse on economic issues and potentially increase public demand for evidence-based policymaking.
Furthermore, the book’s interdisciplinary approach, drawing insights from psychology, sociology, and other fields, could encourage more cross-disciplinary collaboration in economics research. This could lead to a richer, more holistic understanding of economic phenomena and their social impacts.
In the long term, if the ideas in Good Economics for Hard Times gain traction, they could contribute to a shift in how societies measure economic progress and well-being. The authors’ argument for looking beyond GDP growth to more comprehensive measures of societal welfare could influence how governments set economic goals and evaluate policy outcomes.
However, the book’s impact will likely depend on how its ideas are received and implemented by policymakers and economic institutions. If its approach gains widespread adoption, it could lead to more effective, evidence-based economic policies. On the other hand, if its challenges to conventional wisdom face significant resistance, its impact might be more limited to academic circles and progressive policy think tanks.
The Tyranny of Experts by William Easterly
The Tyranny of Experts offers a thought-provoking counterpoint to some of the ideas in Good Economics for Hard Times. While Banerjee and Duflo champion evidence-based policymaking, Easterly cautions against overreliance on expert-driven, top-down development strategies. He argues for the importance of individual rights and bottom-up solutions in economic development. This book provides a valuable perspective on the potential limitations of expert-led interventions and the role of local knowledge and individual agency in economic progress. Readers will gain a more balanced view of the challenges and potential pitfalls in implementing economic policies, especially in developing countries.
Thinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman
Kahneman’s seminal work on cognitive biases and decision-making provides an excellent complement to the economic insights in Good Economics for Hard Times. Thinking, Fast and Slow explores how human thinking and decision-making often deviate from rational economic models. This book helps readers understand the psychological factors that influence economic behavior, which is crucial for fully appreciating the complexities of economic policy-making discussed by Banerjee and Duflo. Kahneman’s insights into risk perception, loss aversion, and other cognitive biases offer valuable context for understanding why economic policies may not always have their intended effects.
The Value of Everything by Mariana Mazzucato
Mazzucato’s book offers a fresh perspective on value creation in the economy, challenging conventional notions about the roles of the public and private sectors. The Value of Everything argues for a more nuanced understanding of how value is created and distributed in modern economies. This aligns well with Banerjee and Duflo’s call for rethinking traditional economic wisdom. Mazzucato’s insights into innovation, public investment, and the shortcomings of GDP as a measure of economic progress provide valuable additional context for the policy discussions in Good Economics for Hard Times.
Factfulness by Hans Rosling, Ola Rosling, and Anna Rosling Rönnlund
Factfulness shares with Good Economics for Hard Times a commitment to challenging popular misconceptions with data-driven analysis. Rosling and his co-authors present a more optimistic view of global progress than is commonly held, based on careful examination of long-term trends. This book complements Banerjee and Duflo’s work by providing a broader historical and global context for understanding economic development. Readers will gain additional tools for interpreting global data and trends, enhancing their ability to engage critically with economic and social issues.
The Great Escape by Angus Deaton
Nobel laureate Angus Deaton’s The Great Escape provides a comprehensive look at global health and wealth inequality, offering valuable context for the discussions in Good Economics for Hard Times. Deaton explores how some parts of the world achieved improved health and prosperity while others were left behind. His nuanced examination of the benefits and challenges of globalization and aid complements Banerjee and Duflo’s work. Readers will gain a deeper historical perspective on global inequality and the complexities of economic development.
Doughnut Economics by Kate Raworth
Raworth’s Doughnut Economics offers an innovative framework for thinking about economic progress that aligns well with Banerjee and Duflo’s call for rethinking traditional economic metrics. Raworth proposes a model of economics that balances essential human needs with planetary boundaries. This book provides valuable insights into how economies might be structured to address social and environmental challenges simultaneously. Readers will gain a fresh perspective on the possibilities for creating more sustainable and equitable economic systems.
Why Nations Fail by Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson
Why Nations Fail provides a compelling analysis of the role of institutions in economic development, offering valuable context for the policy discussions in Good Economics for Hard Times. Acemoglu and Robinson argue that inclusive political and economic institutions are key to long-term prosperity. Their historical approach and emphasis on the importance of institutions complement Banerjee and Duflo’s more policy-focused work. Readers will gain a deeper understanding of the long-term factors that shape economic outcomes and the challenges involved in implementing effective economic policies.
Nudge by Richard H. Thaler and Cass R. Sunstein
Nudge explores how small changes in the way choices are presented can have significant impacts on decision-making, an idea with important implications for economic policy. Thaler and Sunstein’s concept of “libertarian paternalism” offers an interesting perspective on how governments and organizations can influence behavior without restricting freedom of choice. This book provides valuable insights into the practical application of behavioral economics, complementing the policy discussions in Good Economics for Hard Times. Readers will gain a better understanding of how subtle interventions can shape economic outcomes, adding nuance to their understanding of policy implementation.
J-PAL (Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab) Founded by Banerjee and Duflo, J-PAL is a global research center working to reduce poverty by ensuring that policy is informed by scientific evidence. Their website (https://www.povertyactionlab.org/) offers a wealth of resources, including research papers, policy briefs, and online courses on development economics and randomized evaluations. It’s an excellent platform for those interested in diving deeper into the evidence-based approach advocated in Good Economics for Hard Times.
World Bank Open Data This comprehensive database (https://data.worldbank.org/) provides free access to global development data. It covers a wide range of topics including poverty, inequality, health, education, and economic growth. Users can explore, download, and visualize data, making it an invaluable resource for those wanting to fact-check claims or conduct their own analyses of global economic trends.
Our World in Data This website (https://ourworldindata.org/) presents research and data on global development in engaging, interactive formats. It covers many of the topics discussed in Good Economics for Hard Times, including economic growth, inequality, and environmental sustainability. The site’s clear explanations and data visualizations make complex economic concepts accessible to a general audience.
American Economic Association Annual Meeting This annual conference brings together economists from around the world to present and discuss cutting-edge research. While primarily academic, it often features sessions on policy-relevant topics similar to those discussed in Good Economics for Hard Times. The conference website (https://www.aeaweb.org/conference/) provides information on upcoming events and access to papers from past meetings.
World Economic Forum Annual Meeting Also known as Davos, this high-profile gathering (https://www.weforum.org/events/world-economic-forum-annual-meeting-2024) brings together leaders from business, government, and civil society to discuss global economic issues. While not strictly academic, it offers insights into how economic ideas are shaping global policy discussions.
National Association for Business Economics (NABE) NABE (https://www.nabe.com/) is a professional association for business economists and those using economics in the workplace. It offers conferences, webinars, and publications that can help readers apply economic insights in practical business contexts.
International Economic Association (IEA) The IEA (http://www.iea-world.org/) is a federation of national economic associations that promotes international cooperation in economics. Its congresses and roundtables offer opportunities to engage with cutting-edge economic research and policy discussions from a global perspective.
EconTalk Hosted by economist Russ Roberts, EconTalk (https://www.econtalk.org/) features in-depth conversations with economists and other social scientists. While often taking a more free-market perspective than Banerjee and Duflo, it offers thoughtful discussions on many of the same topics covered in Good Economics for Hard Times.
Freakonomics Radio This popular podcast (https://freakonomics.com/series/freakonomics-radio/) applies economic thinking to a wide range of social issues. Its accessible style and focus on counterintuitive findings make it a good complement to the ideas presented in Good Economics for Hard Times.
MITx Micromaster’s Program in Data, Economics, and Development Policy Co-created by Banerjee and Duflo, this online program (https://micromasters.mit.edu/dedp/) offers a deep dive into the methods of modern development economics. It’s an excellent option for those wanting to gain hands-on experience with the research techniques discussed in the book.
Coursera: Economics of Money and Banking Offered by Columbia University, this course (https://www.coursera.org/learn/money-banking) provides a deeper understanding of monetary economics and financial systems, complementing the macroeconomic discussions in Good Economics for Hard Times.
Inside Job Directed by Charles Ferguson, this documentary provides a comprehensive analysis of the 2008 financial crisis. While not directly related to Good Economics for Hard Times, it offers valuable context for understanding the complexities of modern financial systems and the challenges of economic policymaking.
The True Cost This documentary explores the impact of the fashion industry on people and the planet. It provides a concrete example of how global economic systems can have far-reaching social and environmental consequences, themes that are central to Banerjee and Duflo’s work.
Capital in the Twenty-First Century Based on Thomas Piketty’s book of the same name, this documentary explores the history and future of capitalism and inequality. It offers a visual complement to the discussions of inequality in Good Economics for Hard Times, providing historical context and exploring potential future scenarios.
Discover the key takeaways from top non-fiction books in minutes. Get the wisdom you need to succeed fast. Here, learning is quick, engaging, and always at your fingertips.
© 2025 All Rights Reserved.
